
Apple & Spice Rum Mince Pies (Pack of 6)
Our verdict: Apple and rum take the lead.
- Pack
- £7.35 for 6Observed 31 Oct 2026
- Each
- £1.23
- Energy
- 426 kcal per 100g
Find a familiar pack or try another range. Start with a retailer, a name or a dietary need.
198 mince pies and tarts, plus 6 related bakes, from 64 retailers. Prices and labels checked 26 October 2026.

Our verdict: Apple and rum take the lead.

Our verdict: A sharing pie with a Christmas-cake centre.

Our verdict: A six-pack for the undecided.

Our verdict: A classic six with Cognac in the mix.

Our verdict: A classic filling in a smaller case.

Our verdict: Cranberry, orange and port in one pie.

Our verdict: A plant-based take on the classic six.

Our verdict: Vegan minis with a traditional centre.

Our verdict: A creamy after-dinner pie.

Our verdict: A decent everyday six-pack.

Our verdict: An almond-led alternative.

Our verdict: Good fruit, with a divisive pastry.

Our verdict: A little pie for sharing.

Our verdict: An almond tart in mince-pie form.

Our verdict: A rum-flavoured all-butter tart.

Our verdict: A brown-butter pie to seek out.

Our verdict: A chilled dessert in mince pie form.

Our verdict: Fondant takes the place of the lid.

Our verdict: An iced free-from option for four.

Our verdict: A disappointing free-from classic.

Our verdict: A straightforward free-from four-pack.

Our verdict: Puff pastry changes the balance.

Our verdict: Rum and butter make their mark.

Our verdict: The almond overwhelms the fruit.

Our verdict: Irish cream gives this pie its purpose.

Our verdict: Apple crumble in a pastry case.

Our verdict: A smaller take on Asda luxury.

Our verdict: Good fruit, uneven pastry.

Our verdict: A larger-sounding luxury pie, without a twist.

Our verdict: Frangipane meets free-from pastry.

Our verdict: A vegan pie with a pleasant filling.

Our verdict: The everyday six from Asda's bakery.

Our verdict: A shallow pie for pastry fans.

Our verdict: Brownie with mincemeat folded in.

Our verdict: Four larger pies in butter pastry.

Our verdict: A mince pie for Baileys fans.

Our verdict: A dozen traditional Bettys pies.

Our verdict: Four toppings in one miniature box.

Our verdict: Two almond toppings and plenty of fruit.


Our verdict: Chocolate and orange on top of the fruit.

Our verdict: A cocktail-inspired mince pie.

Our verdict: A generous pie under frangipane.

Our verdict: Small pies with an almond finish.

Our verdict: A crumble top for the traditional filling.

Our verdict: A box for people who want a choice.

Our verdict: Traditional shortcrust in a box of six.

Our verdict: A crumble-topped pie with substance.

Our verdict: The classic choice at Nero.

Our verdict: Amaretto and almonds make this the Nero to notice.

Our verdict: Cranberry and orange for sharing.

Our verdict: A traditional brandy pie in a gold carton.

Our verdict: Mince pie filling in a cookie.

Our verdict: A puff pastry alternative in a four-pack.

Our verdict: A small box for shortcrust traditionalists.

Our verdict: A gluten-free listing to check by weight.

Our verdict: A free-from pie with a biscuity finish.

Our verdict: A luxury pie that divides the table.

Our verdict: A generous pie for frangipane fans.

Our verdict: Chocolate and orange with a sharp edge.

Our verdict: Brandy buttercream takes centre stage.

Our verdict: An Irresistible six-pack with a simple brief.

Our verdict: A simple pie with a split verdict.

Our verdict: A straightforward shortcrust six-pack.

Our verdict: Nine small pies for a sharing plate.

Our verdict: A generous traditional pie, better warm.

Our verdict: Twelve small pies for passing round.

Our verdict: A traditional all-butter counter pie.

Our verdict: Citrus leads this coffee-shop tart.

Our verdict: Tea and cranberry make this one different.

Our verdict: A traditional organic six-pack.

Our verdict: Twelve little traditional pies.

Our verdict: Plum and apple change the filling.

Our verdict: A classic pie with balance.

Our verdict: Cranberry and oat crumble on a classic.


Our verdict: An almond-topped Fortnum’s box.

Our verdict: Almond mince pies in petit-four form.

Our verdict: A traditional Fortnum’s six.

Our verdict: Traditional pies in miniature.

Our verdict: A mince pie in a puff pastry roll.

Our verdict: A simple pie with room for more filling.

Our verdict: A classic box from Harrods.

Our verdict: An all-butter four-pack.

Our verdict: The gluten-free Hobbs House option.

Our verdict: A gluten-free pie with citrus lift.


Our verdict: The larger traditional pie.



Our verdict: The traditional Holmes choice.

Our verdict: An affordable pie with mixed results.

Our verdict: Buttery and fruity, with divisive pastry.

Our verdict: Frangipane without a strong almond hit.

Our verdict: A classic six-pack from Jack's.

Our verdict: A single bakery mince pie.
Our verdict: A handmade, deep-filled four-pack.

Our verdict: An all-butter pie with divided opinions.

Our verdict: A modest pie with a spiced filling.

Our verdict: All-butter pastry in miniature.

Our verdict: A very sweet apple crumble pie.

Our verdict: Speculoos crowds out the fruit.
Our verdict: A two-pack for a smaller table.

Our verdict: Four traditional pies from Lottie Shaw's.

Our verdict: Crumble top, without the wheat pastry.

Our verdict: A classic filling in gluten-free pastry.

Our verdict: A mild classic with good pastry.

Our verdict: Cherry and citrus give the classic a turn.

Our verdict: Buttery pastry and a lively fruit filling.

Our verdict: Cherry and chocolate make a dessert of it.

Our verdict: Light pastry, modest filling.

Our verdict: A fruit pie with apple in the lead.

Our verdict: A small pie that favours its pastry.

Our verdict: A sweet choice for icing fans.

Our verdict: Tart fruit lifts the gluten-free pastry.

Our verdict: A malted chocolate alternative to mincemeat.

Our verdict: A brownie pie for the fruit-averse.

Our verdict: A slice of almond tart for the table.

Our verdict: Handmade pies by the half-dozen.

Our verdict: Puff pastry from the bakery counter.

Our verdict: Juicy filling beneath sweet icing.

Our verdict: A crisp free-from pie that crumbles.

Our verdict: A small free-from pie for sharing.

Our verdict: Mince pie flavour in a bun.

Our verdict: An iced six-pack for sweet-toothed guests.

Our verdict: Fruit is the draw, pastry less so.

Our verdict: A bakery-counter shortcrust pie.

Our verdict: Soft pastry and plenty of fruit, for some.

Our verdict: A sweet brandy-butter finish.

Our verdict: Apple and caramel divide opinion.

Our verdict: Bakewell first, mince pie second.

Our verdict: Chocolate orange with a sweet edge.

Our verdict: A deeper pie in a four-pack.

Our verdict: Nine small pies with brandy.

Our verdict: A substantial pie that divides the table.

Our verdict: A familiar all-butter four-pack.

Our verdict: A sweet classic with a snowflake lid.

Our verdict: A mince-pie flavour in a soft whirl.

Our verdict: Wide, sweet and well filled.

Our verdict: A vegan pie that divides opinion.

Our verdict: Frangipane takes the lead.

Our verdict: A rich, generous pie with a chewy filling.

Our verdict: Six larger pies from Reids.

Our verdict: Nine mini pies for a shared table.

Our verdict: Apricot and amaretto in a deep filling.

Our verdict: A fruit-forward organic classic.

Our verdict: A vegan pie that divides opinion.

Our verdict: Organic, in the regular size.

Our verdict: A smaller organic pie for sharing.

Our verdict: Three sorts of miniature pie in a tin.

Our verdict: Good almond topping, variable filling.

Our verdict: Chocolate and brandy in the same pie.

Our verdict: A dependable shortcrust choice.

Our verdict: The whirl can crowd out the fruit.

Our verdict: A classic pie that divides opinion.

Our verdict: A six-pack for icing lovers.

Our verdict: Small pies with a sweet filling.

Our verdict: A mince pie behind every door.

Our verdict: Small pies with proper fruit flavour.

Our verdict: A good free-from fruit pie.

Our verdict: Almond topping and light pastry.

Our verdict: Good fruit beneath a sweet lid.

Our verdict: Little free-from pies with brandy.
Our verdict: A Scottish bakery pie with citrus.

Our verdict: A miniature pie for each December day.

Our verdict: Mini frangipane pies with citrus.

Our verdict: A simple deep-filled six-pack.

Our verdict: The icing can overwhelm the pie.

Our verdict: Amaretto makes its mark.

Our verdict: A buttercream pie with divided loyalties.

Our verdict: Crumble replaces the pastry lid.

Our verdict: A frangipane pie that lacks punch.

Our verdict: Rum can be the star, or go missing.

Our verdict: A sharing box with a divisive balance.

Our verdict: Rich pastry, sometimes too sweet.

Our verdict: Buttery pastry and gentle spice.

Our verdict: Frangipane on a gluten-free pie.

Our verdict: Plenty of filling, plenty of sweetness.

Our verdict: A free-from pie with spice and citrus.

Our verdict: Small pies with a chalky drawback.

Our verdict: Puff pastry with a lattice top.

Our verdict: Sweet, but short on spice.

Our verdict: A salty edge balances the fruit.

Our verdict: The Starry option from Athenry.

Our verdict: Rum and brandy in a flaky pastry pie.

Our verdict: A vegan and gluten-free classic.

Our verdict: Rich pastry, with a divisive filling.

Our verdict: Cranberry and orange with a crumble top.

Our verdict: Nutty little pies with a pastry-heavy bite.

Our verdict: Sour cherry keeps the pistachio in balance.

Our verdict: The filling is sweeter than it is spiced.

Our verdict: Puff pastry changes the classic six-pack.

Our verdict: Orange and spice carry this free-from pie.

Our verdict: A four-pack with a classic fruit mix.

Our verdict: Gingerbread changes the pastry.

Our verdict: A richer filling with whisky in the mix.

Our verdict: A traditional butter pastry and fruit mix.

Our verdict: A mini pie with a traditional filling.

Our verdict: A four-pack for a free-from table.

Our verdict: Amaretto, almond and crumble in one pie.

Our verdict: A Baileys and almond variation.

Our verdict: A mixed box for liqueur fans.

Our verdict: A substantial brandy butter pie.
Try another search or reset a filter.