
All Butter Pastry Mince Pies
Our verdict: A mild classic with good pastry.
- Pack
- £2.50 for 6Observed 31 Oct 2026
- Each
- 42p
- Energy
- 222 kcal per pie

A listing doesn't confirm stock in your local shop. Prices change, so treat each one as dated.
Cherry and chocolate make a dessert of it.
This is a festive pie for people who want to stray from the usual pastry lid. Amarena, Morello and sour cherries meet chocolate buttercream, and the combination works as a fruit-and-chocolate dessert. It is a generous departure from the familiar vine-fruit pie.
The cherry gives it a distinct identity beside M&S Amarena, Blood Orange and Port. The chocolate topping is the deciding factor here, turning the pie towards a Black Forest-style treat.
The filling combines three types of cherry, while a chocolate-flavoured buttercream takes the place of the usual plain finish. That makes the topping a significant part of the choice, especially for anyone who finds a standard mince pie sweet enough already.
Choose these for a dessert plate or for someone who likes cherry with chocolate. A conventional mince pie remains the better choice if you want the familiar emphasis on spice and vine fruit.
One seller listing on record. We note the day we saw each price.
4 in a pack. 218g. Observed 31 Oct 2026. Listing status: available from 2026-11-02. UK; local availability unverified.
Check listingWe couldn't find the full ingredients list in the sources we checked. Ask the seller or look at the current pack.
Not available in the sources we checked.
Contains
Not confirmed in our collected data.
May contain
Not confirmed in our collected data.
If you have an allergy, always check the pack itself.
Not stated means the label we checked didn't say either way.
No nutrition was supplied in the sources we checked.
Compare nutrition across the catalogueNutrition was not supplied in the sources we checked. Check the current pack or seller listing.
Storage and warming instructions weren't supplied in the sources we checked. Follow the pack.
Not supplied in the sources we checked.
No warming instructions were supplied. Check the pack before heating.
Follow the current pack, including packaging removal and appliance suitability. We don't supply timings the manufacturer hasn't confirmed. Storing and warming guide.
Information checked 26 Oct 2026. A live listing doesn't tell us when the recipe last changed.
Other M&S pies in the catalogue. Shown for comparison, not ranked.

Our verdict: A mild classic with good pastry.

Our verdict: Cherry and citrus give the classic a turn.

Our verdict: Buttery pastry and a lively fruit filling.

Our verdict: Light pastry, modest filling.