
Co-op Irresistible Amaretto & Frangipane Mince Pies
Our verdict: A generous pie for frangipane fans.
- Pack
- £2.85 for 4Observed 26 Oct 2026
- Each
- 71p
- Energy
- Not listed
Every pie here has a verdict in its favour. They're grouped by how much we have to go on, not ranked.
29 pies, in brand and name order within each group. How we judge
We have plenty to go on for these, and it points one way.

Our verdict: A generous pie for frangipane fans.
Co-op puts soft frangipane sponge over a generous helping of mincemeat, with amaretto and citrus giving the filling its character. It is a more elaborate prospect than a plain pastry-topped pie, and the almond finish is central to its appeal.

Our verdict: A dependable shortcrust choice.
A sugar-sprinkled lid and shortcrust case keep these pies simple. The pastry has earned praise for its buttery character, and the fruit filling is generous enough to hold its own. It is sold as a bakery-style pack of four.

Our verdict: Amaretto makes its mark.
The amaretto comes through clearly in a generous mincemeat filling, giving these pies an almond sweetness close to a Bakewell. Buttery, crumbly pastry provides a suitable case without hiding that flavour. The box contains four pies with all-butter pastry lids.

Our verdict: Buttery pastry and gentle spice.
Tesco's Finest six have all-butter pastry and a mincemeat filling with brandy and port. The fruit tends towards jammy, with a citrus note and spice that is present without dominating. They keep the familiar closed lid and sugar dusting.

Our verdict: A salty edge balances the fruit.
Crisp shortcrust and a sweet, juicy filling make Plant Chef a strong vegan option. A little salt in the pastry helps balance the mincemeat rather than adding another layer of sweetness. The six-pie box keeps a traditional pastry lid.
A little less to go on, but what there is mostly agrees.

Our verdict: A sharing pie with a Christmas-cake centre.
This large pie gives a table of eight to ten something more like a dessert than a plate of individual pastries. Buttery pastry surrounds a generous fruit filling with the character of an alcohol-soaked Christmas cake. It is a good choice when the filling is the main attraction.

Our verdict: Rum and butter make their mark.
Soft pastry and a rich, rum-laced filling make this a distinctive Exceptional pie. The brown-butter flavour comes through, while the case stays soft rather than soggy. The rum is part of the mincemeat, not an added topping.

Our verdict: Apple crumble in a pastry case.
These tarts taste closer to apple crumble than a traditional mince pie. Soft spiced apple and gentle toffee sit inside a buttery pastry base, with a crumbly topping adding crunch. The spiced crumble replaces a conventional pastry lid.

Our verdict: A mince pie for Baileys fans.
Baileys puts a swirl of creamy icing on top of its mince pies, turning a familiar Christmas bake into something closer to a small dessert. Beneath the topping, soft buttery pastry holds a juicy fruit filling with sweetness and spice.

Our verdict: Two almond toppings and plenty of fruit.
Bettys’ speciality box pairs a rich fruit filling with butter pastry and a sweet almond finish. The frangipane adds texture, making these more elaborate than a pie with a plain pastry lid. It is a box for people who like almond as much as mincemeat.

Our verdict: A generous pie under frangipane.
The handmade Biscuiteers pie gives its spiced fruit filling plenty of room and puts frangipane sponge and almond flakes on top. Cinnamon, ginger and brandy come through in the filling. It is a substantial pie with enough going on to serve as a dessert.

Our verdict: A crumble-topped pie with substance.
A crunchy orange-spiced crumble sits over jammy mincemeat and crisp butter pastry. Salted butter gives the pie a savoury edge against the sweet fruit. It is a substantial four-pack, with enough detail in both topping and filling to make each pie a dessert.

Our verdict: A generous traditional pie, better warm.
COOK's standard mince pie has soft, crumbly shortcrust and a generous helping of fruit filling. It is an uncomplicated traditional pie, and warming it makes a worthwhile difference if you have the oven on for guests.

Our verdict: Citrus leads this coffee-shop tart.
Costa's mince tart has crisp pastry that holds together around a sweet, jammy filling. Citrus is the strongest impression, giving the fruit some brightness, although a little more spice would make the filling feel more rounded.

Our verdict: A classic pie with balance.
DukesHill’s classic mince pies have delicate butter pastry and a fruit filling with enough acidity to keep the sweetness in check. That balance makes them a strong choice for anyone who finds some festive pies too sugary. The six-pack keeps the presentation reassuringly traditional.

Our verdict: Buttery pastry and a lively fruit filling.
Collection gets the important things right. The pastry is crisp and buttery, while the filling brings fruit, citrus and a warming note of alcohol. It is jammy without tasting overwhelmingly sweet. The result is a recognisably traditional pie with more going on than a basic fruit filling.

Our verdict: Tart fruit lifts the gluten-free pastry.
The pastry has a pleasing crumble and the filling brings a welcome tart edge, with a mix of dried fruit. That contrast gives this gluten-free pie more interest than sweetness alone. It keeps the focus on fruit and pastry rather than a novelty topping.

Our verdict: A mince-pie flavour in a soft whirl.
Mr Kipling turns its whirl into a festive sandwich with spiced shortcake, mincemeat-flavour sauce and brandy-flavoured creme. The biscuit is soft and crumbly, and the smooth filling leans towards cinnamon. It borrows mince-pie flavours while keeping the shape and character of a biscuit.

Our verdict: Wide, sweet and well filled.
Mr Kipling's Signature pie is wider and shallower than the usual mince pie, with an open snowflake top and well-coloured pastry. Its dense filling contains plenty of fruit, making the flat shape more substantial than it might first appear.

Our verdict: A rich, generous pie with a chewy filling.
Pump Street's mince pies are sticky and sugar-coated, with rich, chewy mincemeat inside thin butter pastry. They are generous pies, substantial enough that sharing one makes sense if you want just a small sweet course.

Our verdict: A fruit-forward organic classic.
Riverford’s organic mince pies put plenty of fruit and brandy into a traditional-looking bake. They have a homemade appearance and come as a six-pack. The fruit-forward filling makes these a good choice for someone who wants a familiar pie without an elaborate topping.

Our verdict: Small pies with proper fruit flavour.
These minis deliver a light, buttery pastry and a fruity filling with gentle spice. The small size suits a cup of tea without asking you to commit to a full-sized pie. Each has a dusted pastry top and brandy mincemeat.

Our verdict: A good free-from fruit pie.
The filling has a juicy, gently tangy fruit character, with citrus lifting the sweetness. The pastry has a useful middle ground between soft and crisp, although it can feel a little grainy. The filling combines apple and vine fruit in sweet pastry.

Our verdict: Almond topping and light pastry.
These free-from pies combine a crumbly, crisp case with moist frangipane and sweet mincemeat. The topping gives the fruit an almond companion without turning the whole thing into a plain sponge tart. The four pies also contain brandy in the mincemeat.

Our verdict: Little free-from pies with brandy.
These nine minis have sweet pastry and a brandy mincemeat filling. The small format is well suited to sharing when a full-sized pie would be too much. The box contains nine small pies, all with the same filling.

Our verdict: Mini frangipane pies with citrus.
Seven Seeded’s mini pies combine sticky frangipane with rich, sweet pastry and juicy mincemeat. Orange comes through in the filling, giving these small pies a distinct citrus note. They are an appealing choice for guests who like an almond topping on their mince pies.

Our verdict: Sour cherry keeps the pistachio in balance.
Pistachio frangipane and sour cherry take this No.1 pie in a different direction from the usual spiced-fruit classic. The filling is jammy and sharp enough to cut through the sweeter, nutty topping. Its flavours are more dessert-like than traditional.

Our verdict: Orange and spice carry this free-from pie.
This two-pack has a substantial pastry and a fruity filling with orange, spice and treacle notes. The pastry holds together well, though it is not as light or flaky as some alternatives. It has enough fruit to hold its own against the case.

Our verdict: A substantial brandy butter pie.
Wilfreds layers almond frangipane and brandy butter mincemeat in butter pastry, then finishes the pie with crumble. It is a large, sweet proposition, closer to a dessert than the small mince pie you might eat in a couple of bites.
A pie makes this page when our verdict comes down in its favour. Pies we're unsure about, or would skip, stay off it.