
Bally Castle Mince Pies
Our verdict: A creamy after-dinner pie.
- Pack
- £2.49 for 4Observed 31 Oct 2026
- Each
- 62p
- Energy
- 417.5 kcal per 100g
Supermarket packs, bakery boxes and a few odd ones. Compare the prices, read the labels and see what we make of each one before the Christmas shop.

198 pies and tarts from UK supermarkets, bakeries and shops. Labels checked 26 October 2026. Prices carry their own observation dates. Always check the pack.
Tesco Finest 4 Amaretto Mince PiesJoint winner, flavoured mince pies. Good Food, 22 Oct 2026Start from the shop you're standing in. Counts show the mince pies we hold for each one.
All shops and bakeriesIced, all butter, vegan and one with espresso martini. A spread of styles and prices, not a ranking.

Our verdict: A creamy after-dinner pie.

Our verdict: Fondant takes the place of the lid.

Our verdict: A generous traditional pie, better warm.

Our verdict: A classic pie with balance.

Our verdict: A cocktail-inspired mince pie.

Our verdict: An all-butter four-pack.

Our verdict: A traditional organic six-pack.

Our verdict: An almond-topped Fortnum’s box.
Prices are dated observations. Open a product for its seller and price date.
Browse all 198 pies and tartsShort guides built from the same labels and listings as the catalogue.
Ingredients, allergens and the warnings worth checking.
Compare per pie and per 100g, with protein, sugar and the rest of the label.
Ready-made products and the source statement behind each listing.
A closer look at ingredients across the catalogue.
We put labels and seller listings side by side, give our own verdict where there's enough to go on, and show where every fact came from.