
No.1 6 Brown Butter Mince Pies with Cognac
Our verdict: Rich pastry, with a divisive filling.
- Pack
- £4.00 for 6Observed 31 Oct 2026
- Each
- 67p
- Energy
- 386 kcal per 100g
Season not confirmed for 2026. Information checked 26 Oct 2026.

A listing doesn't confirm stock in your local shop. Prices change, so treat each one as dated.
The filling is sweeter than it is spiced.
The all-butter pastry is the promise of this Waitrose six-pack, but the filling has drawn criticism for sweetness and a lack of spice. It is a conventional-looking choice that may disappoint anyone wanting a pronounced festive flavour.
The pastry can seem strongly buttery or bland. The fruit filling is less convincing, with an artificial aftertaste a further drawback.
The difference in views on the pastry makes it hard to recommend on that alone. The common reservation is the filling: a sweet fruit centre with less of the warming spice that many people expect from a mince pie.
This is a mixed choice for a classic mince pie. If you prefer fruit and spice to sweetness, the No.1 brown butter pie offers a more distinctive alternative.
2 seller listings on record. We note the day we saw each price.
6 in a pack. Observed 31 Oct 2026. Listed online, local stock not checked. UK; local availability unverified.
Check listing6 in a pack. Observed 26 Oct 2026. Listed online, local stock not checked. UK, local availability unverified.
Check listingAs collected from the product sources, checked 26 Oct 2026. We haven't checked a physical pack, so read the box before you buy.
Mincemeat (53%) (sugar, mixed vine fruits (sultanas, raisins, currants), apple purée, humectant (vegetable glycerol), apricot, rapeseed oil, glucose-fructose syrup, cherries, orange peel, acidity regulators (acetic acid, citric acid, ascorbic acid), cornflour, cinnamon, lemon peel, colour (plain caramel), nutmeg, sunflower oil, fruit & vegetable concentrates (aronia concentrate, carrot concentrate), lemon oil, orange oil, gelling agent (pectin)), wheat flour (wheat flour, calcium carbonate, folic acid, iron, niacin, thiamin), butter (milk) (13%), sugar, rice flour, salt, raising agents (disodium diphosphate, sodium hydrogen carbonate).
Allergens are in bold.
Contains
May contain
The source says: "For allergens, including cereals containing gluten, see ingredients in bold. May contain: nuts." If you have an allergy, always check the pack itself.
Vegetarian (source). Not stated means the label we checked didn't say either way.
From the label, as listed. Check the current pack for changes.
Compare nutrition across the catalogueInstructions as collected from the product sources. Follow the current pack if it differs.
Keep flat Store in a cool dry place.
Once opened store in an airtight container. For best quality we recommend you consume within 7 days. For best before date see side of pack. Freeze as soon after purchase as possible and within the best before date. Use within one month. Defrost fully before use: do not refreeze once defrosted. Once thawed, use within 7 days. Consume within 7 days
Oven cook(From Chilled)
May be eaten hot or cold. Preheat oven. Remove all packaging. Place pies on a baking tray and heat in centre of oven. Mincemeat filling can be very hot after heating. (Time 8-9 mins, Oven: 160°C, Fan: 140°C, Gas: Gas Mark 3)
Serves 6
Follow the current pack, including packaging removal and appliance suitability. We don't supply timings the manufacturer hasn't confirmed. Storing and warming guide.
Information checked 26 Oct 2026. A live listing doesn't tell us when the recipe last changed.
Other Waitrose pies in the catalogue. Shown for comparison, not ranked.

Our verdict: Rich pastry, with a divisive filling.

Our verdict: Cranberry and orange with a crumble top.

Our verdict: Nutty little pies with a pastry-heavy bite.

Our verdict: Sour cherry keeps the pistachio in balance.