
All Butter Pastry Mince Pies
Our verdict: A mild classic with good pastry.
- Pack
- £2.50 for 6Observed 31 Oct 2026
- Each
- 42p
- Energy
- 222 kcal per pie

A listing doesn't confirm stock in your local shop. Prices change, so treat each one as dated.
Buttery pastry and a lively fruit filling.
Collection gets the important things right. The pastry is crisp and buttery, while the filling brings fruit, citrus and a warming note of alcohol. It is jammy without tasting overwhelmingly sweet. The result is a recognisably traditional pie with more going on than a basic fruit filling.
Cognac, brandy, orange peel and cranberries give this six-pack a more elaborate filling than the M&S classic. The pastry has enough character to stand alongside it. Some may still want more fruit for the amount of pastry.
The filling leans into orange as well as dried fruit, so its sharper notes help offset the richness of the pastry. Cognac and brandy add warmth without turning the pie into a novelty flavour. It is more involved than the plain classic.
A good choice for a traditional Christmas table with a little more richness. Pick the classic if you want a simpler, milder pie, and this one if citrus and a boozy filling appeal.
3 seller listings on record. We note the day we saw each price.
6 in a pack. Observed 31 Oct 2026. Listed online, local stock not checked. UK; local availability unverified.
Check listing6 in a pack. 351g. Observed 26 Oct 2026. Listed online, local stock not checked. UK, local availability unverified.
Check listing6 in a pack. Observed 26 Oct 2026. Listed online, local stock not checked. UK, local availability unverified.
Check listingAs collected from the product sources, checked 26 Oct 2026. We haven't checked a physical pack, so read the box before you buy.
Mincemeat (Sultanas · Glucose Syrup · Apple Purée · Sugar · Vostizza Currants · Glacé Cherries (Cherries · Glucose-Fructose Syrup · Concentrated Carrot Juice · Concentrated Aronia Juice · Acidity Regulator: Citric Acid) · Candied Orange Peel (Orange Peel · Glucose-Fructose Syrup · Sugar) · Cranberries · Cognac · Brandy · Raisins · Rapeseed Oil · Gelling Agent: Pectin (from Fruit) · Cornflour · Concentrated Orange Juice · Lemon Peel · Ground Spices (Cinnamon · Nutmeg · Black Pepper) · Preservative: Acetic Acid · Black Treacle · Acidity Regulator: Citric Acid · Orange Oil) · Wheatflour* · Sugar · Butter (Milk) · Brown Butter (Milk) (6%) · Rice Flour · Salt · Raising Agent: E450, Sodium Bicarbonate · Sea Salt · Invert Sugar · Emulsifier: E471. *Fortified with Calcium, Iron, Vitamins B3, B1 and Folic Acid. Contains alcohol. May contain fruit stones and stalks. The filling in this product will be particularly hot after heating.
Allergens are in bold. The filling contains Cognac, Brandy.
Contains
May contain
The source says: "* Not suitable for those with a Nut allergy. * Not suitable for those with a Peanut allergy. * Not suitable for those with a Nut allergy. * Not suitable for those with a Peanut allergy." If you have an allergy, always check the pack itself.
Vegetarian (source). Not stated means the label we checked didn't say either way.
From the label, as listed. Portion: Per 59g mince pie. Check the current pack for changes.
Compare nutrition across the catalogueInstructions as collected from the product sources. Follow the current pack if it differs.
Suitable for freezing.
For Best Before, see side of pack. Store in a cool, dry place. Once opened, store in an airtight container. Freeze by date mark shown and use within 3 months. Defrost thoroughly before use.
Oven cook - From Ambient. Electric 180°C / Fan 160°C / Gas 4, 8-10 mins - Preheat oven - Remove carton and plastic tray - Do not remove from foil cases - Place on baking tray Do not reheat.
Follow the current pack, including packaging removal and appliance suitability. We don't supply timings the manufacturer hasn't confirmed. Storing and warming guide.
Information checked 26 Oct 2026. A live listing doesn't tell us when the recipe last changed.
Other M&S pies in the catalogue. Shown for comparison, not ranked.

Our verdict: A mild classic with good pastry.

Our verdict: Cherry and citrus give the classic a turn.

Our verdict: Cherry and chocolate make a dessert of it.

Our verdict: Light pastry, modest filling.