
Rodney the Reindeer Pies
Our verdict: A brownie pie for the fruit-averse.
- Pack
- £3.50 for 4Observed 31 Oct 2026
- Each
- 88p
- Energy
- 455 kcal per 100g
Announced for Christmas 2026. Information checked 26 Oct 2026.
A related festive alternative without mincemeat. This sits outside our mince pie comparisons.

A listing doesn't confirm stock in your local shop. Prices change, so treat each one as dated.
A malted chocolate alternative to mincemeat.
These cookie pies swap festive fruit for a blondie-style centre, caramel and milk chocolate. Malted buttercream and caramel flakes finish them, making the four-pack a dessert for people who would rather have chocolate than mincemeat.
The malt gives the sweetness a useful counterpoint, and the topping and pastry bring different textures. There is plenty going on in a small pie, so it is a richer alternative than a conventional fruit filling.
Brown butter pastry holds the blondie filling, while the buttercream supplies a separate malted layer. The caramel flakes add another element to the topping. It is a busy combination and will suit a sweet tooth more than a search for Christmas spice.
Put these alongside mince pies when not everyone wants dried fruit. They are a festive bake in the same shape, with a very different filling.
2 seller listings on record. We note the day we saw each price.
4 in a pack. 183g. Observed 31 Oct 2026. Listing status: listed; local stock unverified. UK; local availability unverified.
Check listing188g. Observed 26 Oct 2026. Listed online, local stock not checked. UK, local availability unverified.
Check listingAs collected from the product sources, checked 26 Oct 2026. We haven't checked a physical pack, so read the box before you buy.
Wheatflour* · Sugar · Butter (Milk) · Dark Brown Sugar · Water · Rapeseed Oil · Pasteurised Egg · Malted Barley · Brown Butter (Milk) · Milk Chocolate (Sugar · Cocoa Butter · Dried Whole Milk · Cocoa Mass · Dried Whey (Milk) · Lactose (Milk) · Emulsifier: Soya Lecithin · Natural Flavouring) · Dried Skimmed Milk· Wheat Gluten · Humectant: Glycerol · Glucose Syrup · Black Treacle · Sea Salt · Dried Glucose Syrup · Cornflour · Sweetened Condensed Milk (Whole Milk · Sugar) · Fat Reduced Cocoa Powder · Natural Flavouring · Raising Agent: E450, Sodium Bicarbonate · Gelling Agent: Pectin (from Fruit) · Emulsifier: Lecithin · Salt. *Fortified with Calcium, Iron, Vitamins B3, B1 and Folic Acid.
Allergens are in bold.
Contains
May contain
The source says: "* Not suitable for those with a Nut allergy. * Not suitable for those with a Peanut allergy. * Not suitable for those with a Nut allergy. * Not suitable for those with a Peanut allergy." If you have an allergy, always check the pack itself.
Vegetarian (source). Not stated means the label we checked didn't say either way.
From the label, as listed. Check the current pack for changes.
Compare nutrition across the catalogueInstructions as collected from the product sources. Follow the current pack if it differs.
Not suitable for freezing.
For Best Before, see side of pack. Store in a cool, dry place. Once opened, store in an airtight container.
No warming instructions were supplied. Check the pack before heating.
Follow the current pack, including packaging removal and appliance suitability. We don't supply timings the manufacturer hasn't confirmed. Storing and warming guide.
Information checked 26 Oct 2026. A live listing doesn't tell us when the recipe last changed.
Other M&S pies in the catalogue. Shown for comparison, not ranked.

Our verdict: A brownie pie for the fruit-averse.